Penalty and Subproblem Methods era
The Penalty and Subproblem Methods era (1965–1987) saw constraint handling through penalty-based reformulations and master-subproblem decomposition that framed constrained NLP as tractable sequences of subproblems. Fiacco and Ishizuka developed sequential unconstrained minimization techniques and penalty-function frameworks that turn constrained problems into successive unconstrained subproblems with increasing penalty parameters. Rockafellar's Banach-space Lagrange multiplier theory provided a rigorous nonsmooth-optimization foundation for these approaches, while J. F. Benders popularized master-subproblem architectures that separate a difficult problem into solvable subproblems. In the later phase, Grossmann and Duran introduced the outer-approximation framework for MINLP, and Katarina Svanberg's moving-asymptotes method offered stabilized, convex subproblems that bridged penalty ideas with proximal-type strategies.